Yes. Without hesitation. I would send the same message again, probably around the same date, with nearly the same wording. The holiday felt more focused, less transactional, and much more manageable financially. For me, that trade was worth it.
The biggest proof came after Christmas, when nobody was trying to remember who gave what or whether we had properly reciprocated. We just moved on with our lives. No weird resentment, no giant credit card regret, no house full of extra clutter. Just a nice family day and a saner December.
15. If you’re thinking about doing this in your own family
My advice is simple. Say it early. Be warm, not apologetic. Keep the explanation short. Make your rule clear enough that nobody has to decode it. If you can, pair the change with something positive, like a shared meal, a game, a cookie exchange, or a donation tradition.

Also, be prepared for the possibility that people may need a minute. Change lands differently on different personalities. The planners will want details. The sentimental people may hear loss first. The practical people will probably text you, “Honestly, thank you.” Let everybody have their reaction without treating it like a crisis.
What happened in my family was not a holiday disaster. It was a reset. And once we got through that initial discomfort, what remained was the part of Christmas I had actually been trying to protect all along: less pressure, more presence, and a day that felt like family instead of a spending contest.
